Tool
Dialogue Tag Auditor
The auditor counts speaking verbs, notices when a colourful tag has become a tic, counts adverb-on-tag constructions, and looks for action beats. It will not scold you for said. Said is the point. The tool is here to catch hissed-five-times and the scene where nobody ever touches anything.
4 tags · said-family 50% · beats spotted 1 · adverb tags 1
- said 2
- asked 1
- snapped 1
What it counts
A fixed list of speaking verbs is matched as words, so said and snapped and whispered are counted, and smiled is not counted as a tag because it isn’t one. Smiled and nodded and walked show up in the beat tally instead. That split is the pedagogy. If your beat count is high because everyone shrugged, you have not been praised. You have been measured.
Adverb tags are phrases like said softly or quietly asked. They are notes, not sins. The workshop ban on adverbs is an overcorrection that taught a generation to fear information. Keep the adverb that argues with the line. Cut the one that repeats it. The tool can only show you the pile.
Any tag other than said, says, asked, or asks that appears three times in the pasted passage is flagged as a tic. Three is arbitrary and local to the passage. In a novel, three hissed across four hundred pages is nothing. Three hissed on one page is a performance of intensity. Paste the scene, not the book, if you want the flag to mean something.
Said is not a problem to solve
If the said-share is near 100 and the beat count is zero, the flag you get is about floating talk, not about invisible verbs. The fix is not murmured, breathed, or opined. The fix is a beat that changes the room: a chair unused, a form unsigned, a kettle that clicks off while nobody pours. Readers do not count said. They count whether they know who is in charge.
Writers sometimes arrive from a teacher who marked said wrong. This page is the counter-argument, with a counter you can run. Variety of tags is not the same as variety of voices. Voice is diction and tactic, and it is discussed in the character-voice guide. A tag auditor that demanded synonyms would be joining the bad lesson. This one refuses.
Share the counts if you are in a group. The link carries totals — tags, adverb tags, said percentage — and not the lines. That matters if the scene is unpublished, which it should be allowed to stay. A critique that requires you to upload a chapter to a random server is a different product. This isn’t that.
Limits
It cannot see tags split from their quotes by a line of narration in a clever way, and it will count the word said inside dialogue (“You said you’d be here”) as a tag. That inflates the said-share. If your characters are lawyers of promises, expect noise. The explanations are written so you can discard them. A tool that won’t be argued with is a bad teacher.
Non-English speech verbs are invisible. So are dialogue systems that use dashes instead of tags. Don’t run a French novel or a screenplay through this and conclude you have no technique. The instrument is for tagged English prose. Know the instrument’s country.
It also cannot hear mockery. A phonetic dialect pasted here may show a calm tag report while still being a caricature. The sensitivity guidance on the voice and historical pages is the relevant tool for that, and it is a human one. Don’t outsource ethics to a counter.
A teaching note
A useful exercise: run the auditor, then rewrite the scene using only said and beats, then run it again. Read both aloud. Students discover that intensity was in the situation, or that it wasn’t and the bookisms were hiding a slack want. Either discovery is worth more than a clean printout.
If you are preparing pages for a manuscript critique, do this pass first so the editor can talk about structure instead of hissed. You will have spent their fee on the part you couldn’t automate. That is the correct division of labour between a counter and a person.
A worked pass that leaves said alone
Count a page by hand once, so you trust the machine later. Circle said. Underline every other speaking verb. Put a dot on every adverb glued to a tag. You will usually find that said is common and invisible, that hissed or murmured has shown up three times because you were bored, and that the adverbs agree with lines that were already sad. The auditor should tell you the same story. If it scolds said, it is broken, and this one is not supposed to. Said is the default because the line should be doing the work.
Rewrite using only said and beats. “I’m fine,” she said brightly becomes either “I’m fine,” she said, with the blood still on the cuff, or “I’m fine.” She capped the pen. Keep the adverb only when it fights the sentence. Run the auditor again. The colourful-verb count should drop. The scene should not get politer. If the rewrite made everyone reasonable, you sanded off the want while you were sanding off the bookisms. Put the rudeness back. Bookisms were never the rudeness. They were the costume the rudeness wore when the line itself was thin.
Do this per scene. A whole manuscript averaged together hides the chapter where a single argument hisses. Manuscript critiques and book editors notice that chapter immediately, because a tic is louder than a plot. Fix the tic before you pay someone to find it. Then spend the fee on structure, voice, and the question of whether the scene belongs. A tag report is not a developmental edit, and it should not be priced like one. If the report and your ear disagree, trust the ear and check that you pasted the scene you think you pasted.
Questions
- Is using said too much a mistake?
- No. Said is invisible because readers don’t pronounce it as a word they notice. The mistake is a scene of tags and no behaviour, or a scene that avoids said by cycling through louder verbs. The auditor treats said as healthy and treats repetition of other verbs as a tic.
- How many adverbs are too many?
- On a tag, more than the number that change meaning. The tool waves a flag at three in one paste so you look. It does not delete them. A single adverb that contradicts the line should survive every pass, including this one.
- Does it upload the page?
- No. The count is local. Sharing copies the totals into a link and leaves the prose on your machine.
- Why didn’t smiled count as a tag?
- Because it can’t speak. If you wrote “hello,” she smiled, you have a punctuation problem and a logic problem. The punctuation checker is the one that flags the comma. This one files smiled under beats, where the body belongs.
- Can I audit a whole novel at once?
- You can paste a lot of text, and the tic threshold of three will become silly. Audit scenes. A novel’s average hides the page where everyone suddenly starts hissing.
Related: dialogue tags vs action beats · common dialogue mistakes · dialogue punctuation fiction
Educational material from The Dialogue Lab. Not a substitute for a copy editor, a script consultant, or legal advice.